Dogs and hop plants
I had a humbling and learning moment a while ago with an online interaction on one of the forums I frequent. I have absolutely no idea why it popped into my head the weekend before Christmas. Even less a clue why I was reminded of it while doing dishes.
I referenced what I thought to be a well known “fact” about hop poisoning in dogs. There were two anecdotal accounts of dogs eating a sizable amount of hop cones. The animals both had elevated temperatures and started to seize. One story ended in the dogs death while another was able to be saved.
It had always been gospel truth in my head that hop plants were bad news around dogs. Why? Well, my brother told me very early on when we both just started getting into brewing, and I read and re-read it on the Internet.
Yup, there’s a great quote for you, “it must be true, I read it on the Internet.”
So I referenced this well known “truth” in an online discussion. Another member of the forum corrected me, saying my information is wrong and he had never heard of that. I replied with an “almost common knowledge among brewers”, meaning, of course, HOMEbrewers.
This is where it gets interesting. Turns out the fellow who replied correcting me just happens to be a brewer and distiller. No, not a HOMEbrewer, someone who went to school specifically to create a product for sale.
Oh, and from what I have since learned, one of his accomplishments places him as one of three in the US. So here I am, a rank amateur spouting what I thought was the truth being corrected by a professional. Someone whose product I have consumed quite a bit! Humble pie for one, please.
There are two things that stick out really well here. First, I learned to question a lot of what I “know” to be true. Particularly when it comes to brewing and wine making. I hear myself telling my students years ago to verify what they read on the Internet. They couldn’t just cite a website for a reference without having a name to go along with it.
Second, no matter how much I think I know, someone always knows more. Definitely incentive to keep striving for greater knowledge!
Cheers,
Tony
Posted on 21st December 2008
Under: General Beer | 2 Comments »
