Malcolm Island and bear politics
We spent an idyllic, sunny day on Malcolm Island back in May so I was eager to return when we were in the area again. This time we took our car so that we could drive to the other side of the island and hike the Beautiful Bay Trail. We had learned from a local in May that there are never any bears on the island, so we didn’t bother taking our bear spray along and we detached the bear bells from Monkey’s bag.
We got to the trailhead to find a sign warning us that there was a bear in the area. Not just any bear, but a grizzly bear. We all know that there are no grizzly bears on Vancouver Island, but it appears that recently young grizzlies have been swimming over from the mainland more and more, due to having too much competition for food and territory in their original habitat. These bears cannot stay on the Island as they threaten the habitat of the black bears and other animals that rightfully call the territory their own. Normally a grizzly that has swum over will get shot when it is caught, rather than being shipped back to its original area, as it is likely that it left for good reason in the first place.
It seems a bit unfair to get in the way of evolution like this, but humans are pretty much causing the evolution in the first place with a combination of over-fishing and the ideological shift towards wildlife conservation over hunting. There are more and more bears in the wild but, unfortunately, less and less food for them to eat, so the bears need to move on or starve. And if they move on they get shot because, ultimately, humans are at the top of the food chain and we do not want to get into a situation where we allow the bear to become a threat to that status.
It’s sad really, but life certainly isn’t fair for bears. I’m not a great fan of hunting, but the more I live in this country the more I can see the case for it, at least from the point of view of population control. The problem of too many bears and too little food is huge and if it isn’t controlled it will eventually lead to many more cases of bear attacks against humans for 3 reasons: 1) bears viewing humans who enter their territory as competition for food; 2) more bears coming into residential areas in order to find food (e.g. in trash cans); 3) bears eventually realising that humans aren’t generally out to harm them, becoming less scared of them and starting to see them as prey rather than predator.
Back to Malcolm Island….the date of the bear sighting was far enough removed from the actual date that we decided to go ahead with the hike anyway, and we found another set of bear bells in my bag. The trail was lovely and very well maintained - I was really enjoying the hike.
Unfortunately we didn’t stay on it for too long because the wind started picking up. The odd noises that were eminating from the trees (including some very ominous cracking sounds) were enough to spook us into exiting the forest fairly quickly. We didn’t want to be the victims of a falling tree, or a confused grizzly bear that hadn’t smelled/heard us coming. I think we made the right choice, even though we later found out from a local that the grizzly bear had moved on to the main island a few days ago.
When we got back into the car we decided to take a long drive up towards the tip of the island where the lighthouse is. You can’t drive to the lighthouse because the last part is private property, but you can park up at the gates and walk down to the beach, following the shoreline to the lighthouse. We weren’t feeling particularly sociable so we decided not to say hello to the Lighthouse Keeper, but we walked along the beach a fair way and just sat in the sun watching the ocean for a long time before driving back to the ferry terminal.
We had dinner at Gus’ Pub in Port McNeill (we didn’t bump into John Lovelace this time, we’d obviously had our ration of famous people for the day) before heading back to our accommodation - Hidden Cove Lodge - to watch a nice sunset and have an early night in preparation for the day’s kayaking ahead.
Posted on 17th September 2008
Under: Travel | 1 Comment »
























