This was the most bizarre season for running backs. Not just for the number who were injured, but the amount that were total busts.
Perusing my rankings from last summer, I’m shocked at the mess RBs became. I knew it was a rough season, but I didn’t realize how brutal it really was until I saw my list again. Out of my top 20, I’d say only seven lived up to their potential. The other 13 were beset by injuries and/or were busts to varying degrees. And that’s not including LaDainian Tomlinson, who disappointed by not having another superhuman season. Even some of the successful running backs did well despite injuries (Bryan Westbrook and Joseph Addai) — that’s how rough a season it was.
Here is my after-the-fact top 15:
1. LaDainian Tomlinson, Chargers
2. Adrian Peterson, Vikings
3. Joseph Addai, Colts
4. Brian Westbrook, Eagles
5. Clinton Portis, Redskins
6. Marshawn Lynch, Bills
7. Edgerrin James, Cardinals
8. Jamal Lewis, Browns
9. Marion Barber III, Cowboys
10. Maurice Jones-Drew, Jaguars
11. Willis McGahee, Ravens
12. Willie Parker, Steelers
13. Ryan Grant, Packers
14. Fred Taylor, Jaguars
15. Brandon Jacobs, Giants
Before I highlight who isn’t on this list, it’s interesting how there weren’t many complete running backs this year. Parker rushed for 1,316 yards and just two touchdowns. Jones-Drew scored 9 touchdowns yet only rushed for 768 yards. Taylor was the opposite, with 1,202 yards and five touchdowns. And McGahee, despite nice stats, never seemed a reliable fantasy option week to week.
Now, for the big names who missed this top 15: Frank Gore, Larry Johnson, Steven Jackson, Laurence Maroney, Reggie Bush, Rudi Johnson, Shaun Alexander, Thomas Jones, Travis Henry, Ronnie Brown. Admittedly, if I went to 20 instead of 15, Maroney, Jackson and Gore might have made it (along with LenDale White and Earnest Graham). Brown was having a monster season before injury derailed it. And Gore and Jones did top 1,000 yards, though Gore produced only two 100-plus-yard weeks (and scored TDs in just three games) and Jones finished with only one touchdown. But if you were relying on any of these omissions as your RB1, I hope you found an adequate replacement as the season went along.
As for next season, I doubt there will be a sudden exodus from running backs in the first round. Even with Parker’s lack of touchdowns, he’s still too reliable of a yardage gainer to not take in the top 10. Larry Johnson healthy is a first-rounder. Maroney came on nicely late and should be back in the top 10, and Bush is too much of a dual threat to ignore beyond the second round. And after Peterson and Lynch’s rookie success, expect Darren McFadden to go high. Then pray it’s not another atypical year for running backs.