I could name you a dozen tight ends to draft this year. I could do this because the top 12 tight ends are mostly consistent from cheat sheet to cheat sheet.
I’m not going to say the dropoff is at No. 12, because Randy McMichael, Heath Miller or Owen Daniels aren’t that far off in fantasy terms than the couple TEs right before them. I was just surprised that from six different sources, the top 12 tight ends were the same, with the exception of one player in one cheat sheet. That’s an unusual consensus for so many players.
Antonio Gates is the runaway No. 1. The next six TEs are somewhat interchangeable, with Tony Gonzalez holding a slight edge and Vernon Davis and Chris Cooley in this group more for their potential than last year’s stats. If there is a dropoff, it’s after Cooley or Ben Watson, going down to about Tony Scheffler at No. 16. Still, that’s pretty good depth for a position that once was a fantasy wasteland several years ago.
1. Antonio Gates, Chargers
2. Tony Gonzalez, Chiefs
3. Jeremy Shockey, Giants
4. Todd Heap, Ravens
5. Vernon Davis, 49ers
6. Alge Crumpler, Falcons
7. Chris Cooley, Redskins
8. Ben Watson, Patriots
9. Kellen Winslow, Browns
10. Jason Witten, Cowboys
11. L.J. Smith, Eagles
12. Dallas Clark, Colts
13. Randy McMichael, Rams
14. Heath Miller, Steelers
15. Owen Daniels, Texans
16. Tony Scheffler, Broncos
17. Daniel Graham, Broncos
18. Desmond Clark, Bears
19. Greg Olsen, Bears
20. David Martin, Dolphins
21. Chris Baker, Jets
22. Bo Scaife, Titans
23. Alex Smith, Buccaneers
24. Eric Johnson, Saints
25. Marcus Pollard, Seahawks
26. Visanthe Shiancoe, Vikings
27. Marcedes Lewis, Jaguars
28. Ben Troupe, Titans
29. Zach Miller, Raiders
30. Leonard Pope, Cardinals
31. Jerramy Stevens, Buccaneers
32. Jermaine Wiggins, Jaguars
33. Robert Royal, Bills
34. Dan Campbell, Lions
35. Donald Lee, Packers
36. Ben Utecht, Colts
37. Bubba Franks, Packers
38. Reggie Kelly, Bengals
39. George Wrightster, Jaguars
40. David Thomas, Patriots
41. Jeff King, Panthers