With the playoffs set, I began to ponder which team that didn’t make the postseason suffered the biggest, most shocking collapse in 2008. Several came to mind:
– Green Bay. The Packers weren’t exactly a playoff lock, but they started the season out decently enough, and with a new starting quarterback, no less, that they had a legititmate shot to win the NFC North. Instead, thanks mostly to injuries and not Aaron Rodgers, they finished 6-10.
– Dallas. Had Tony Romo not broken his finger, would the Cowboys have finished 11-5? Difficult to say, especially since there were games they barely showed up. And there was no excuse for not being competitive against the Eagles on Sunday when a playoff berth was on the line.
– Denver. The Broncos were 8-5 with a three-game lead in the AFC West and just needed one win or one Chargers loss to win the division. It didn’t happen, though two of Denver’s losses were to good teams (if you count San Diego as a good team; by Week 17, the Chargers were). However, the Broncos should have defeated Buffalo in Week 16. Maybe they weren’t that good to begin with and just benefited from playing in a mediocre division.
– N.Y. Jets. The Jets went from 8-3 and the hottest team in the NFL to 9-7 and out of the postseason. The collapse cost Eric Mangini his job and made some people reflect that maybe the Packers knew what they were doing when they let Brett Favre go.
– Washington. The Redskins started 6-2 and finished 2-6. They can’t blame playing in a tough division, either, for losing to the Rams, Bengals and 49ers.
– Buffalo. Another great start, another disappointing midseason. At least for the Bills, you can blame the tough division. Losing Trent Edwards for a few games didn’t help, either.
But the winner of the biggest collapse in 2008: Tampa Bay. The Bucs were 9-3 and driving toward a playoff berth, then lost out, including their last two at home to AFC West opponents. How embarrassing is it to be prevented from making the playoffs by the Raiders? For perspective, a less experienced Falcons team coming off a terrible 2007 showed more poise than the Bucs when the playoffs were on the line. Tampa Bay had no excuse.