Draft-ermath
Another NFL Draft is in the books, and we enter another nine-month period without Mel Kiper Jr. I’m not a big draft enthusiast and didn’t follow it much beyond the first round, but here are some of my initial thoughts following a weekend filled with new NFL rookies:
– The Lions got their quarterback in Matthew Stafford, then picked up perhaps the best tight end in the draft in Brandon Pettigrew. Where Stafford may haven an advantage over other No. 1 QB busts (Tim Couch, David Carr, Alex Smith …) is that he’ll have some decent players surrounding him on offense, notably WR Calvin Johnson. Granted, I don’t think the Lions will finish better than 4-12 this season, but the team’s low expectations might help Stafford — there will be less pressure on him to win right away. He’s not going to have a Joe Flacco/Matt Ryan type of playoff rookie season, but he’s not going to be the scapegoat if the Lions only win a few games (which of course, will be an improvement upon last year).
– The Jets got their quarterback, too, by trading up to No. 5 for Matt Sanchez. I was a little surprised the Seahawks didn’t take Sanchez, but that’s the Jets’ gain, who now have their quarterback of the future. Here’s the conundrum, however: Do you let him start right away and hope he has the Flacco/Ryan success (after all, the Jets aren’t that bad a team), or do you give him a year to learn behind Kellen Clemens and risk Clemens turns in a career season (a la Drew Brees and Derek Anderson)? There will be more pressure on Sanchez than on Stafford in Detroit; I’d say let him wait a year to start.
– The Raiders stayed true to their perplexing form by taking receiver Darrius Heyward-Bay about 20 picks too soon. They don’t really have a quarterback to get the ball to him, and there were better WRs on the board, but why should that matter to the Raiders and their history of dumb moves? One draft pundit said maybe Oakland was enamored with his speed; perhaps the team was hoping for a Chris Johnson-type steal. But at least Johnson went to a decent Titans team and shared time with a complementary running back; Heyward-Bay is going to a bad team with bad receivers. If they wanted him so bad, couldn’t the Raiders have figured out a way to trade down to still draft Heyward-Bay and get their money’s worth?
– Six receivers were taken in the first round — double the amount of running backs. The 49ers felt like they must have hit the jackpot when Michael Crabtree fell to them, and Jeremy Maclin gives Donovan McNabb another young target in Philadelphia.
– Why did the Bucs draft Josh Freeman — in fact, they traded up for him — when they already had four quarterbacks on their roster? Here’s a prediction: Tampa Bay will finish last in the NFC South after none of the five pan out.
– Finally, the Chiefs took a cue from fantasy football by taking a kicker (Ryan Succop) with the last pick of the draft. I’m not sure why the team didn’t draft a bigger need and just sought out through free agency and extra kicker, but at any rate, Mr. Irrelevant is ironically at a position many football purists wish was … irrelevant.
Posted on 26th April 2009
Under: NFL news, notes, and unsolicited opinions | No Comments »
