A Hypothetical Ethical Hunting Challenge
Posted by Jeff Cash on November 18, 2009 | Leave a Comment
Maine is one of the many states in the U.S. that permits the taking of only one whitetail deer except in a very limited number of circumstances such as being specially drawn in a lottery system for a bonus permit for example.
With that said I have a hypothetical ethical hunting challenge scenario to present you with in the hope that you will search your own heart to determine what you would feel about the situation, what actions you might take if you were to find yourself in this or a similar situation and in the end to just stimulate some thought in the minds of hunters on the issues of hunting ethics.
The Scenario
You have been hunting for several days with a few sightings but no clear shot opportunity thus far. You were lucky enough to secure some time off from your job to hunt this year but that time is dwindling down. Additionally you travel a significant distance to and from your hunting location which carries an additional expense for you and is of course a regular issue with your spouse each time you come home empty handed. Needless to say you’re feeling some pressure to tag out.
So on this particular day you are on stand in the woods. It is around 23 degrees Fahrenheit and you have been on site for about two hours fighting off cold feet and really glad you wore that extra layer of insulated clothing you got for your birthday last year. The sun has risen above the horizon a while ago and from time to time appears through the branches of the mixed hardwood forest and it’s scattered islands of spruce breaking up the terrain.
You suddenly hear some crunching in the distance and begin focusing in the direction you think you heard it, approximately your 2:00 direction. You peer between the trunks and branches of the trees and spot some movement. A few seconds later you make out the figure of a deer walking straight towards you! It clearly has not seen you as it walks slowly and seemingly without any concerns about it’s surroundings. It is about 100 yards away from you and you cannot tell if there are antlers or not at this point. Good thing you got an any-deer permit this year!
At about 50 yards away it is still heading straight towards you as it disappears and then reappears traveling through the forest maze. You soon see what you believe are antlers that extend beyond the ears on either side of the deer’s head. They appear to be quite thin with little mass but a nice wide spread just the same. You were hoping to see a buck and your heart begins to beat just a little heavier in your chest as you realize this bruiser is probably in the 180 to 200 + pound range.. If only this buck would present a clean broadside shot opportunity!
At about 20 yards the buck stops with it’s head hidden behind a clump of trees sniffing the air. Recognizing this as perhaps your best and last opportunity to raise your rifle into shooting position you do so very slowly, your heart beating harder and faster with every passing second. You hold this position waiting and hoping the buck steps out from behind the trees giving you that desired broadside heart/lung shot your father taught you to execute for a quick kill. It seems like forever as you continue to wait.
Finally this buck steps to it’s left (your right) out from behind the clump of trees giving you a clear shot just behind that front shoulder! You take careful aim confident in your rifle and your own skill for this very close 20 yard shot. You release the safety. You slowly pull the trigger.
BANG!
The buck, rather than bound off as you would expect from a miss, lowers it’s head and body and runs hard to your right. It is running incredibly fast zipping past the heavy forest growth way too fast to allow a follow up shot. You notice it is running low and hard and you feel confident you hit this majestic creature as you desperately watch it hoping to see it drop.
It doesn’t drop. It continues to run and quickly disappears from your sight as you hear it crashing through the trees beyond your vision. That’s ok you tell yourself. It should be easy enough to track with such a solid hit to it’s vital area. You wait a minute or so sitting still resisting the urge to rush right out in search of your prey.
After a minute or so you walk over to the spot the deer was in when you fired. You search the ground and the surrounding branches, leaves and brush for blood, hair or any other sign of a successful hit. You don’t see any.
You see the tracks of the deer and the aggressive and abrupt tearing up of the earth when it bolted. You start to follow those tracks thinking you will see blood at any moment.
You follow the buck’s path for 10 then 20 yards. Still no sign of blood. 30 yards, then 50 yards and still no sign of blood.
The tracks soon begin to criss cross other tracks as this is a heavily traveled area for the local deer population. You do your best to stay on your deer’s unique trail but after several crossings with other tracks you feel uncertain as to whether you are looking at your deer’s track or one of the many others that have mingled with it going in every direction.
And you still see no sign of a successful hit.
The thought begins to set in that maybe you missed this deer. At 20 yards you may have missed this big buck? You took such careful aim. You didn’t rush the shot. You feel you did everything right. It even ran like it had been hit. But where is the sign?
You start to feel a combination of disgust and embarrassment. The evidence seems to support a miss but you were sure you hit it. But the evidence seems so clear. You don’t want to believe it but you eventually come to the conclusion that you must have missed it.
Angry and disgusted with yourself you end up leaving the woods early starting the long disgusted drive home.
Now, our scenario isn’t quite over yet folks although I hope you are already thinking about the presented series of events. Now hold on to your hats …..
The following day you are home after spending the last 24 hrs stewing over your apparent misfortune, self-doubt, etc. You receive a call from a friend or family member. They ask you if you shot a buck the day before!
It seems a fellow hunter found sometime after you left the woods a nice buck a few hundred yards from the very spot you were at yesterday. It was suspected that you might be the shooter but no one that morning knew how to contact you as you had left early and in an on the spot decision one of the hunters, a friend or family member, decided it better to tag the buck than to leave it for the coyotes so that is what they did.
Didn’t expect that one did you!
Now in this hypothetical challenge I ask you to search yourself to determine what you would do in the face of this fictional situation.
Would you demand that the buck you shot be turned over to you?
Would you continue your hunting season as if you had never shot the deer?
Would you consider your season as ended?
Would you consider your killing of this deer the literal completion of your circle of life and death for this year or would you consider that circle incomplete and unfulfilled in spite of being presented with and, with your pulling of the trigger, your acceptance of this deer’s gift to you?
Would you quit hunting altogether in disgust?
Would you seek further skill training in the area of tracking your prey?
Would you feel guilty for the event the way it played out?
Would you feel at peace knowing the animal’s life was in the end not wasted in spite of your failure to locate it?
How would a series of events such as this impact your future hunts?
Would you feel you did all you reasonably could have done under the circumstances?
Would you react in some other way?
Would you not react at all to the situation?
I invite you to share your thoughts on how you would feel or react to this type of situation. For those who do not feel comfortable sharing your responses publicly I hope you have your own internal debate to better assess your own ethical or moral reaction.
Maybe in our self examinations we will all become better and more responsible hunters.
May your hunt be blessed.
Jeff Cash
Posted on 18th November 2009 by Jeff Cash
Under: Philosophy, Safety, family, hunting, nature, spirituality | No Comments »




