For much of human history, we have tended to think of the number of fish in the sea as an endless quantity. Unfortunately, that belief is looking more and more like an illusion.
Sharks and barracuda disappear on Caribbean coral reefs as human populations rise, endangering the region’s marine food web, its reefs and its fisheries, finds a new study by researcher Chris Stallings of the Florida State University Coastal and Marine Laboratory.
Stallings says overfishing is the most likely cause of the Caribbean’s present lack of big fish.
With far more detail at a greater geographic scale than any other research to date, Stallings examined 20 species of predators, including sharks, groupers, snappers, jacks, trumpetfish and barracuda, from 22 Caribbean nations.
“I found that nations with more people have reefs with far fewer large fish because as the number of people increases, so does demand for seafood,” said Stallings.
“Fishermen typically go after the biggest fish first, but shift to smaller species once the bigger ones become depleted,” he said. “In some areas with large human populations, my study revealed that only a few small predatory fish remain.”
When you get right down to it, the only thing that can be changed in this equation is human behavior. Either we learn to act with some restraint and manage the ocean’s resources responsibly, or face the consequences.
“Large predatory fish such as groupers and sharks are vitally important in marine food webs,” Stallings said. “However, predicting the consequence of their loss is difficult because of the complexity of predator-prey interactions. You can’t replace a 10-foot shark with a one-foot grouper and expect there to be no effect on reef communities. Shifts in abundance to smaller predators could therefore have surprising and unanticipated effects. One such effect may be the ability of non-native species to invade Caribbean reefs.”
A case in point, said Stallings, is the ongoing invasion by Pacific lionfish, which were introduced by aquarium releases.
“Lionfish are minor players on their native Pacific reefs, yet they are undergoing a population explosion and overeating small fishes in the greater Caribbean region,” said Professor Mark Hixon of Oregon State University, Stallings’ doctoral advisor at OSU.